A Rick Warren Headline, with Disappointment This Time

warren            Rick Warren is arguably the best known Southern Baptist in America and maybe the world. As founding pastor of Saddleback Church, he has been on the leading edge of innovation of ministry in our day.  His books The Purpose-Driven Church and The Purpose-Driven Life have impacted millions.  He is an effective and articulate spokesman for evangelical Christians.  His recent prayer at the presidential inauguration was handled with grace and truthfulness. I have learned much from him and expect to continue.


            Last week, Rick and Saddleback did something that really disturbed me.  In honor of their 30th Easter as a church, they made a push to have a huge number of people compete their new members’ class.  OK.  As with many churches, they present the gospel for those who may not know Christ and encourage people to trust Him. OK.  


            This promotion just went too far.  Listen to some of the wording:


Which of these requirements do you need to complete this Saturday?

1.  Open your heart to Jesus Christ.

2.  Attend Class 101: Discovering Your Church Family.

3.  Sign our membership covenant (explained in class).

4.  Be baptized the way Jesus commanded and modeled for us.



             I understand this is shorthand for Saddleback’s entire church membership process.  I know Rick doesn’t believe or teach this in the class, but the implication is that trusting Jesus as Savior and Lord is equivalent to attending the class and signing the covenant. 

            It gets worse. Rick gives eight reasons not to procrastinate on this. His personal involvement leads the list.  The promise of a photo, certificate and magazine subscription is next.  You get your name on a commemorative list. The class is an hour shorter than usual. This class will be part of Christian history by being the largest membership class ever. (Really? In the global scheme of things Christian in our generation, this is what makes history?)

            Note there’s no mention of gospel or eternal realities. No Biblical pleading for souls.  It’s all organizational. 

            By all measures, it was a successful event. Saddleback baptized 800 people last week. We can celebrate that and pray for the eternal reality of those professions. But even their own press release gives pause. Six members from one small group were baptized together and it was described like this: “It’s good to see God at work in so many people’s lives… This is what the small group community is about and what Pastor Rick is always talking about. It’s amazing to be able to live and participate in the reality of it.”  How does an individual response to the gospel connect with this sort of shared group response?

            Now, the point of this is not to slam mega-churches; nor is it a condemnation of those who embrace church growth methodologies or purpose-driven ministries.  I have seen Class 101,and have no doubt that the gospel was presented clearly.  Saddleback also  has one of the most clear (and practiced) church membership covenants among Southern Baptists, who are generally very soft on meaningful membership. 

Here is my concern:  the manner in which this was promoted to the church body dilutes and confuses significant doctrinal issues around salvation.

+ It confuses the solitary call of the gospel of salvation by grace alone through faith alone (Eph. 2:8-9), by connecting “open your heart to Jesus” with other actions.

+ It makes the gospel seem like a check-list to complete rather than a miraculous response of the soul to the Spirit’s power described in John 3

+ It dilutes the broken-hearted repentance for sin that is essential to response to the gospel by making it sound like part of a great deal that won’t take long on a Saturday morning.

+ It feels too much like a sales pitch than a pleading for a soul. 

With all the Kingdom good they do and influence they hold, I just wish Saddleback would be more careful and precise with their language in discussing the gospel. 


4 responses

  1. One of the strong points of the Southern Baptist Church is their organization, it also can be one of their weak points. Years ago while in the Military stationed in Anchorage Alaska I attended the large downtown S. Baptist Church. The sermon was excellent, but at the end the Pastor gave the altar call by saying, “Come on down to the front, give God your heart, me your hand and join the Church”. If I wasn’t already a believer, I would have thought, shake the preacher’s hand and join the Church and then I would be a Christian. I never went back, I instead went to a smaller church in a residential area where the Gospel was better explained and the pastor and congregation saw you as a person and not part of the membership goal.

  2. It reminds me of Oprah’s big give away – “You get a car! You get a car!” Just substitute the word Jesus in place of car. How sad to reduce salvation to a gimmick on any given Sunday.

  3. […] you posted an invitation to the baptism and membership, some bloggers criticized the promotion. In the promotion, you said new members could have their photo […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: