Grinch-y Christians

On a fairly regular basis, conservative evangelical Christians drive me crazy.  Now, I know it’s my own tribe, and so there are moments when I’m right next to them, driving other people crazy. 

But I am specifically talking about the conservative evangelical Christians who consider themselves culture warriors.  Who walk around with a chip on their shoulder about 4 feet wide.  Who are constantly looking for a fight.  Who live their lives and their faith angry at the world in which they have been placed.

And believe it or not, Christmas makes it worse. 

I know all sorts of troubling things have happened recently.  Schools started calling it the “winter holidays” and insisted that choirs sing only secular songs of the season.  Communities have been forced to remove nativity scenes from the town square. A couple of years ago, some companies, in a bow to political correctness, instructed their employees to wish their customers “Happy Holidays!” rather than “Merry Christmas!”

That last one seemed to really tick the warriors off most of all.  There were petitions, calls for boycott and more.

As the season began this year, news came that some companies had reversed their policies about such greetings.  “Merry Christmas” is back, and the warriors proclaimed victory, with a certain smugness in blog posts and fund-raising letters.

Then came this news that just makes you shake your head.

The historic First Baptist Church of Dallas, a leading light of Southern Baptist conservatism for a half-century or more, announced that this Christmas, they were issuing “Grinch Alerts”.  The church began a web site, where people can post the names of businesses they do not think are properly recognizing the true meaning of Christmas.  

In other words, the church has taken upon itself to develop a sort of “naughty or nice” list, although the emphasis is clearly on the “naughty”. A business could be placed on the list for could be customer greetings, store displays or merchandise offered that some deem offensive.  The pastor, Robert Jeffress said, “”Too many businesses have bowed down to political correctness. I thought this would be a fun way to call out businesses that are refusing to celebrate Christmas.” The church’s radio station (which I am sure advertises itself as “safe for the whole family”) will provide daily updates on the list.

Words fail.

It is cheap and dumb.  It is a gimmick that cheapens the nature and mission of the church.   It plays into the worst stereotypes of Christians—angry, narrow-minded, judgmental, etc.  It ignores the reality of the times in which we live and instead lives inside the fantasy of Bible Belt culture. It is embarrassing to Christ-followers attempting to build relationships with far-from-God people. It does not even match the intent of the great Dr. Seuss story, which his biographer said was about “enabling the heart to grow larger” and speculated that Theodore Geisel would have “loathed” the campaign. In an ironic twist, it focuses attention on the commercial and economic aspects of Christmas rather than the spiritual.  

Mostly, “Grinch Alert” is utterly devoid of the gospel.  There is no sense of grace or love or joy or hope.  There is no welcoming of all people to consider the Christ of Christmas.  Indeed as a Jewish rabbi noted, “this kind of campaign feels mean to remind me and people like me that we are second-best members of society.” Ouch.

Why would Pastor Jeffress consider it “fun” to point out – in a publicly mocking and economically hurtful way—people who may be choosing to not recognize the precious beauty and meaning of the birth of Jesus?  We have a name for people like that: they are spiritually lost.   They are simply acting, speaking or marketing the way spiritually lost people act, speak or market. 

So no, this is not fun; it is mean and condemning.  And mean does not reflect the heart of a loving God who passionately seeks after the lost to bring them Home. Mean should not be attached to a people who are supposed to Christ-followers.  Mean and love just don’t go together.

Instead of acting like the Grinch at the start of the story, we’re supposed to be a living demonstration of the Grinch after he discovered the true meaning of Christmas. We who have been given massive grace in the face of our own small-heartedness should delight to give it away to others. 

Campaigns to mobilize ticked-off Christians merely play to the conservative evangelical Bible Belt choir to make us feel better about talking to ourselves rather than actually doing the mission to which we have been called and engaging the culture in which we actually live. Remember, it is a mission to “seek and save that which is lost.” (Luke 19:10)

Instead of a Grinch Alert, we would be better served to issue a Grace Alert.  Listen:

 And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us, and we have seen his glory, glory as of the only Son from the Father, full of grace and truth…. And from his fullness we have all received, grace upon grace. For the law was given through Moses; grace and truth came through Jesus Christ….

For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life. For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but in order that the world might be saved through him.    (John 1:14, 16-17; 3:16-17)


3 responses

  1. […] more or less. I’m not sure I could do better than the analysis offered by David Head [link], with a couple of disclaimers. I agree with Head that shows of political or economic force are not […]

  2. Thank you for your insight on this. You succinctly put into words, what greatly disturbed my heart about this.

    When I first heard about the “naughty/nice” list (I live in the Dallas/Fort Worth area), I was without words, and in disbelief that a large metropolitan church (that I generally respect, I must add) from our area was taking such a potentially public/hurtful stance against main-stream businesses. It never seems to puzzle me why believers spend their efforts targeting businesses with attempts to get the people who run them to stand for something that isn’t obviously in their hearts (especially when it isn’t encroaching on our rights to worship/obey Jesus or walk out our own faith). These types of campaigns simply do not reconcile with the biblical example of how we are to interact with “the world.”

    There are no Christian businesses — there are only businesses run by (imperfect, but covered by God’s Grace) Christians and businesses that are run by (imperfect, but lost) non-Christians. Let’s leave it to the Better Business Bureau to decide if a business is “naughty or nice,” rather than trying to correct the actions of a non-believer that are not truly correctable without the foundation of knowing the Lord. Let’s instead, as Christians focus our resources on our true calling: spreading the love and truth of Jesus and passing along an eternal knowledge of Him.

    That said, I do feel like I need to clarify one thing you said about the radio station (KCBI) which, yes, is supported by the church who came up with this misguided idea. I listen to them regularly, and I have not yet heard any updates to the “nice/naughty” list. In fact, the only time I heard them mention this list was right after Thanksgiving. I wondered if it might have struck a similar “off” chord with the station managers, as when the DJ spoke about it, she seemed hesitant. She “framed” the information with a reminder to listeners to prayerfully consider their own hearts (and take the log out of their own eye), before deciding to post a business to the “naughty” list. KCBI is actually a wonderful station with normally solid teaching/discipleship (Charles Swindoll, James McDonald, David Jeremiah, Nancy Lee DeMoss, etc.). They are truly a “light on the hill” in our city.

    As a side-bar, I have silently followed your blog for over a year. Thank you for your heart-felt messages ~ they always speak to the core of my heart and your blog is a regular read and “God nudge” for me.

    A joyful Christmas to you and yours.

  3. Thanks for your “on-site” insight!! You’re right that there is a way to deal with the world that both maintains our integrity and leaves open a door for bearing witness to the good news of Jesus.
    Also, your gracious comments are a real encouragement…thanks!
    Have a blessed Christmas!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: